RRSP vs. TFSA

Find out how they work and how you can benefit from them.

Connect with an advisor to open an RRSP and a TFSA. 

Find an advisor

TFSA or RRSP: Which one should you invest in?

Choosing the right savings solution can be challenging for Canadians, with the Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) and Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) being two popular options. Each offers unique advantages but determining which best suits your needs requires careful consideration.

What's a TFSA? 

TFSAs are registered investment accounts that allow Canadians to save money through various qualified investments, including mutual funds, segregated funds, and insurance GICs.

What's an RRSP?

RRSPs are registered plans designed to help Canadians save for retirement, offering tax benefits by allowing you to deduct contributions from your income and deferring taxes on investment growth.

To help you make an informed decision, we've created a comprehensive comparison table. This guide outlines the advantages of both TFSAs and RRSPs across different life stages and financial goals, allowing you to choose the option that aligns best with your personal circumstances.

Should you invest in an RRSP or a TFSA?

Life Stage/Goal RRSP TFSA
First-time home buyer Borrow up to $60,000 from an RRSP to purchase a home if you're a first-time home buyer. This can help you get into the housing market sooner.  Use TFSA funds for a down payment or make mortgage payments at your own pace – without worrying about tax implications. This offers flexibility in managing your home purchase. 
Starting out in life Try to avoid RRSP withdrawals until you're further down the road – like after you retire. This strategy helps maximize long-term growth. Save or make tax-free withdrawals to pay off a wedding, honeymoon, or couples vacation. This allows you to enjoy life events without tax concerns.
Starting a family Start building your nest egg while taking care of your family. Keep your RRSP contributions going. This helps secure your family's financial future while potentially reducing your current tax burden.  Set aside money to grow tax-free and make TFSA withdrawals to help cover new baby expenses and the cost of raising children. The tax-free nature of these withdrawals can be particularly helpful during this potentially costly time. 
Travel plans You're better off using TFSA to save for travel. That way, you can avoid a tax hit that would come with RRSP withdrawals.  Save up money tax-free in a TFSA and use it to fund your solo, family or couples travel plans. This allows for flexible, tax-free savings for your adventures.
Returning to school Got the itch to go back to school? Borrow up to $20,000 ($10,000 per year) from your RRSP with the Lifelong Learning Plan. This can help finance your education without fully cashing out your retirement savings or incurring upfront tax.  Save for and use your TFSA funds to pay tuition fees, then carry forward unused contribution room to save money after graduation. This offers a tax-efficient way to manage education costs and future savings.
Approaching retirement As you approach retirement, try to max out your RRSP contributions each year. This can help reduce your taxable income now and build your retirement nest egg.  Continue to grow your money in a TFSA and pull funds when you're ready to retire. This provides a tax-free supplement to your retirement income.
Starting retirement You can save money in your RRSP until age 71. When you retire (at 65, 71, or whenever), there's a good chance your income (and tax bracket) will be lower. This means you could pay less tax when making RRSP withdrawals, optimizing your retirement income.  Want or need to keep working and saving a bit longer? There's no maximum age limit for you to contribute to a TFSA. Use your TFSA as a source of retirement income whenever you want, offering flexibility in your retirement planning. 
Leaving a legacy RRSPs allow you to name a beneficiary, simplifying the transfer of assets after you die. Keep in mind that RRSPs are taxable upon death, unless transferred to a qualified beneficiary (such as a spouse or common-law partner, financially dependent minor child or grandchild, or financially dependent disabled beneficiary). This flexibility can help provide financial protection for your loved ones while potentially minimizing tax implications.  Your TFSA earnings remain tax-free even at death. Plus, you can name a beneficiary on almost all TFSA accounts. This way, you can leave money to your loved ones outside of your estate, potentially simplifying the transfer of assets.

Key factors that can influence your choice 

Choosing between a TFSA and an RRSP depends on your personal situation. Here are some factors to consider: 

Your income level and tax bracket 

  • Higher-income earners often benefit more from an RRSP's tax deduction 
  • Lower-income earners may gain more long-term value from a TFSA because they receive less benefit from RRSP tax deductions

Your time horizon 

  • RRSP: Better for long-term (retirement) savings because contributions are tax-deductible 
  • TFSA: More flexible for medium-term goals (home, travel, education)

Withdrawal flexibility 

  • RRSP: Withdrawals are taxed and your contribution room doesn’t regenerate. 
  • TFSA: Allows tax-free withdrawals at any time1. When you withdraw from your TFSA, you will regain the same amount as new available contribution room on January  1 of the following year

Employer matching

  • If your employer offers RRSP matching, it's often worth prioritizing for the immediate return. Your employer may also offer TFSA matching

Your financial goals 

Your decision may depend on what you want to achieve financially: 

  • Saving for a first homei? An RRSP Home Buyer’s Plan (HBP) or even a First Home Savings Account (FHSA) 
  • Planning for retirement? An RRSP is designed for this 
  • Building an emergency fund? A TFSA is your best option

When a TFSA makes more sense 

  • Your income is low or varies 
  • You might need to access funds early 
  • You're just starting to invest and unsure of your goal 
  • You've already maxed out your RRSP

When an RRSP makes more sense 

  • You're in a higher tax bracket and want to reduce taxable income 
  • You expect to have a similar or lower income during retirement 
  • You have a stable, long-term investment plan 
  • You can reinvest your tax refund for extra growth

Real-life scenarios 

Here are some situational examples that may help you make your decision:

Who you are Better savings option Why it's good for you
Student or new worker earning less than $45,000 TFSA
  • You won't get much tax benefit from an RRSP now 
  • Money in a TFSA grows without being taxed and can be withdrawn tax-free at any time.
Mid-career worker earning $70,000 to $90,000  RRSP
  • You save on taxes right away 
  • Your money grows tax-deferred over time for retirement
Self-employed person with changing income

TFSA
  • You can take money out easily if needed 
  • You won't pay tax on withdrawals 
  • You can take money out without paying taxes or penalties. However, for the HBP, you must repay the withdrawn amount to an RRSP over 15 years, starting 2–5 years after withdrawal, or the unpaid amount will be taxed as income.
Planning to buy a home RRSP, HBP or FHSA
  • You can take money out easily if needed 
  • You won't pay tax on withdrawals 

You can take money out without paying taxes or penalties. However, for the HBP, you must repay the withdrawn amount to an RRSP over 15 years, starting 2–5 years after withdrawal, or the unpaid amount will be taxed as income. 
Close to retirement RRSP or TFSA

Both options have benefits depending on your timeline:

 

  • RRSP converts to a RRIF (Registered Retirement Income Fund) later 
  • You don't pay taxes until you take money out (RRSP) 
  • TFSA offers tax-free growth and withdrawals with no impact on income-tested benefits 
  • Consider your years to retirement when choosing which to prioritize

A Sun Life advisor can help you better understand your financial situation, invest your money wisely, and meet your financial goals through personalized assessment, recommendations, and ongoing guidance.

Enter your postal code below to find an advisor near you.

This information is meant for educational and illustrative purposes only. Some conditions, exclusions and restrictions apply.